A full list of credits, including fandoms and ships used, and the lovely people who created the icons, can be found underneath the cut.
Clicking on each ship name will take you to the recs posted at the community for each pairing—although we do have one ship (Jane the Virgin - Jane Villanueva/Rafael Solano) with no recs yet. If somebody wants to rec this pairing, I’ll edit this list!
Finally: THANK YOU. We couldn’t have done it without all of you.
Top Row:
Castle, Kate Beckett/Richard Castle, icon by
Marvel Comics, Natasha Romanoff/Bucky Barnes, icon by
Farscape, Aeryn Sun/John Crichton, icon by
Luther, Alice Morgan/John Luther, icon by
Pride and Prejudice, Elizabeth Bennet/Fitzwilliam Darcy, icon by
The 100, Clarke Griffin/Bellamy Blake, icon by
Outlander, Claire Fraser/Jamie Fraser, icon by
Mulan, Fa Mulan/Li Shang, icon by
Edge of Tomorrow, Rita Vrataski/William Cage, icon by
Pacific Rim, Mako Mori/Raleigh Becket, icon by
Gilmore Girls, Lorelai Gilmore/Luke Danes, icon by
Fullmetal Alchemist, Winry Rockbell/Edward Elric, icon by
Sleepy Hollow, Abbie Mills/Ichabod Crane, icon by
Middle Row:
Elementary, Sherlock Holmes/Joan Watson, icon by
Battlestar Galactica, Laura Roslin/William Adama, icon by
Doctor Who, River Song/The Doctor, icon by
The West Wing, Donna Moss/Joshua Lyman, icon by
Iron Man, Pepper Potts/Tony Stark, icon by
Harry Potter, Hermione Granger/Ron Weasley, icon by
Wicked, Elphaba Thropp/Fiyero Tiggular, icon by
Anne of Green Gables, Anne Shirley/Gilbert Blythe, icon by
Tron, Quorra/Sam Flynn, icon by
Selfie, Eliza Dooley/Henry Higgs, icon by

Arrow, Oliver Queen/Felicity Smoak, icon by
New Girl, Jessica Day/Nick Miller, icon by
The X-Files, Dana Scully/Fox Mulder, icon by
Bottom Row:
DC Comics, Wonder Woman/Superman, icon by
The Americans, Elizabeth Jennings/Phillip Jennings, icon by
Firefly, Zoe Washburne/Hoban Washburne, icon by
The Mummy, Evelyn Carnahan/Rick O'Connell, icon by
Leverage, Parker/Alec Hardison, icon by
X-Men, Rogue/Remy 'Gambit' LeBeau, icon by
Once Upon a Time, Emma Swan/Killian Jones, icon by
Agents of SHIELD, Melinda May/Phil Coulson, icon by
The Mindy Project, Mindy Lahiri/Danny Castellano, icon by
Jane the Virgin, Jane Villanueva/Rafael Solano, icon by
Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries, Phryne Fisher/Jack Robinson, icon by
Veronica Mars, Veronica Mars/Logan Echolls, icon by
Stargate SG-1, Samantha Carter/Jack O’Neill, icon by